Rochester's Go-To Realtors for Buying and Selling
Welcome to the Rochester Realtors directory! Whether you're hunting for your first place or finally ready to sell, you'll find local agents here who know our neighborhoods inside and out.
Map of Businesses in Rochester
All Listings in Rochester
9 businesses
Anthony Butera Team at Keller Williams Realty
Real estate agency📍1770 Long Pond Rd, Rochester, NY 14606, United States
NORCHAR Real Estate
Real estate agent📍389 Park Ave, Rochester, NY 14607, United States
R Realty Rochester LLC, Rochester Real Estate
Real estate agency📍86 Lake Ave, Rochester, NY 14608, United States
Alan Wood - RE/MAX
Real estate agency📍2171 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618, United States
Elysian Homes by Mark Siwiec and Associates
Real estate agency📍1357 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618, United States
High Falls | Sotheby's International Realty
Real estate agency📍1655 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618, United States
Sharon Quataert Team with Century 21 Apex
Real estate agency📍2170 W Ridge Rd, Rochester, NY 14626, United States
The Jeff Scofield Team Real Estate Agents
Real estate agency📍2171 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618, United States
WCI Realty
Real estate agency📍2450 W Ridge Rd # 202, Rochester, NY 14626, United States
About Realtors in Rochester
Here's something that surprises people moving in from the coasts: Rochester is a market where a house can feel absurdly affordable on paper and still get three offers in a weekend. Cheap and competitive at the same time. That tension defines how Realtors work here.
The housing stock is old. Really old, in a lot of places. Think early-1900s Colonials, Tudors, and two-family houses, plus a big ring of mid-century ranches and split-levels in the suburbs. Newer construction exists, but it's the exception rather than the norm, and that limited supply is a big reason well-priced homes in decent school districts tend to move quickly when they hit the market.
Demand comes from a familiar mix: healthcare and higher-ed employment, a steady stream of first-time buyers priced out of pricier metros, and move-up families chasing specific school districts. Investors show up too, especially for the city's many two- and three-family properties. The agent landscape feels fragmented—a handful of big-name brokerages with lots of agents under their banners, and a long tail of independents who know a few neighborhoods inside and out. 📍
And that last part matters. In Rochester, neighborhood knowledge isn't a bonus. It's most of the job.
Park Avenue / Neighborhood of the Arts
- Area Profile: Walkable, café-and-restaurant-heavy, popular with young professionals and a creative crowd. Older homes with real character.
- Realtors Activity: Move-up buyers and renovation-minded first-timers. Condos and apartments mix in with single-family homes.
- Price Range: Commonly in the $200,000–$450,000 range, depending on condition and street.
- Local Note: Walkability is the selling point. Agents here sell a lifestyle, not just square footage.
Browncroft
- Area Profile: A leafy, architecturally cohesive neighborhood on the city's east side, with an active neighborhood association and a strong sense of identity.
- Realtors Activity: Families and longtime owners. Homes here often draw serious interest when they list.
- Price Range: Often in the $250,000–$500,000 range.
- Local Note: Buyers tend to be drawn by the housing style and tree-lined streets, and agents who know the architectural details have an edge.
Pittsford
- Area Profile: Affluent suburb with a well-regarded school district and a village center along the Erie Canal.
- Realtors Activity: Move-up and luxury buyers, plus relocating professionals.
- Price Range: Broad—from roughly $350,000 into the high six figures and well beyond for estate-level homes.
- Local Note: The school district is the engine. Many buyers start their search there and work backward.
📊 Current Price Points:
- Budget options: roughly $100,000–$200,000 (city starters, fixer-uppers, older suburban ranches)
- Mid-range: roughly $200,000–$350,000 (the bulk of family homes)
- Premium: $400,000+ (Pittsford, Brighton, and select city pockets, often climbing well higher)
📈 Market Trends:
- Demand has stayed healthy relative to supply—more buyers than good listings, especially in the lower and middle tiers.
- Inventory runs tight. Well-priced homes can disappear fast, while overpriced ones sit.
- Pricing has leaned upward over recent years, though sensitivity to interest rates keeps the pace uneven.
- Spring is the listing surge. Winter is quieter.
- Time on market varies wildly: a few days for a hot listing, a couple of months for one that's mispriced.
💰 What People Are Spending:
- Starter single-family homes: commonly $150,000–$250,000
- Move-up family homes in sought-after districts: often $300,000–$500,000
- Two- and three-family investment properties: a wide range, typically $120,000–$300,000
- Condos and townhomes: frequently $130,000–$300,000
Economic Indicators:
- Population has been roughly flat to slightly shifting rather than booming—this isn't a growth-spurt metro.
- Major anchors are well known: the University of Rochester and its medical center, Rochester Institute of Technology, and a large healthcare presence. Legacy names like Kodak and Xerox still color the city's identity even as the economy has diversified.
- New residential development exists but is modest compared with fast-growing Sun Belt cities.
Local Market Dynamics:
Because the population isn't exploding, price pressure comes mainly from limited supply, not a flood of newcomers. That distinction matters. Housing stays relatively affordable, yet good homes still draw multiple offers.
Competition among agents is spread out. You'll find big brokerages with recognizable signs and plenty of solo agents with deep roots in a single neighborhood. Interest-rate swings tend to ripple through here the same way they do elsewhere—buyers hesitate, then rush back.
How This Affects Buyers:
Practically speaking? Affordability is a genuine draw, but you can't count on a sleepy market. Get pre-approved before you tour. Know your ceiling. And expect that a well-priced home in a good district may not wait for you to "think about it."
Rochester Seasonal Patterns:
- ☀️ Spring/Summer: peak listing and buying season. More choice, more competition.
- 🍂 Fall: activity eases, and motivated sellers who missed the spring rush may be more flexible.
- ❄️ Winter: fewer listings and fewer buyers. That can mean more negotiating room, though selection is thin.
- 📅 Peak months: spring is when to move fast; late fall and winter is when to negotiate.
Timing Tips for Rochester:
- Buyer leverage tends to be best in late fall through winter.
- Listing inventory generally peaks in spring.
- Families often aim to close before the school year starts, which pushes demand into late spring and summer.
- A typical transaction commonly runs about a month to two months from accepted offer to closing.
Smart Timing Tips:
- ✓ Get pre-approved before spring so you can act quickly.
- ✓ Tour in bad weather—you'll learn how a house handles Rochester winters (and its basement).
- ✓ If you're selling, list when your neighborhood's buyers are most active, usually spring.
- ✓ Don't ignore winter listings—less competition can mean better terms.
Credentials to Verify:
- Confirm an active New York real estate license. You can verify it through the New York Department of State, which handles real estate licensing.
- Know the difference: a "Realtor" is a licensed agent who is also a member of the National Association of Realtors and bound by its Code of Ethics. Not every licensed agent uses the term.
- Look at reviews and recent transaction history to see how active an agent really is.
Questions to Ask:
- How long have you worked in Rochester specifically?
- Can I speak with recent local clients?
- What's your commission structure, and what's negotiable?
⚠️ Red Flags Specific to Rochester Realtors:
- Pressuring you to use their in-house lender or title company without shopping around
- Practicing dual agency without clearly disclosing it upfront
- Reluctance to put commission terms and representation agreements in writing
- Pushing you to waive contingencies without explaining the real risk
Where to Check Complaints:
- New York Department of State (licensing)
- Better Business Bureau
- Google and Yelp—look for patterns across many reviews, not a single glowing or angry one
✓ Established presence in Rochester, not just passing through
✓ Verifiable local reviews and references
✓ Transparent pricing, no hidden fees
✓ A clear process explained upfront
✓ Responsive communication
Won't put anything in writing
Dodges questions about dual agency or fees
Can't speak knowledgeably about the neighborhoods you care about
Pressures you into a rushed decision or to skip inspections
Cost Calculator
Professional Tools
Realtor Calculators
Smart tools to guide your clients through every step of the transaction.
US Market · 2025
Home Value Estimator
CMA-style price range for your listing
Year Built
2005
Lot Size (acres)
0.25 ac
Estimated Value Range
Based on market comps & property data
Fill in property details to see estimate
Seller Net Sheet
Exactly what your seller walks away with
$
$
Agent Commission
5.5%
$
$
$
$
Seller Net Sheet
Estimated proceeds at closing
Enter sale details to calculate proceeds
Rent vs. Buy Analyzer
Which makes more sense for your client?
$
Down Payment
10%
Mortgage Rate (APR)
7.0%
$
Annual Home Appreciation
4.0%
Time Horizon (years)
7 yrs
$
Rent vs. Buy Analysis
5-year financial comparison
Enter details to compare options
Agent Income Planner
Project your annual GCI & take-home pay
$
Transactions per Year
18
Your Commission Side
2.5%
Broker Split (you keep)
70%
$
Self-Employment Tax Rate
25%
Income Projection
Annual earnings breakdown
Set your goals to see projection
Property Tax Calculator
Annual & monthly tax burden by state
$
Assessment Ratio
100%
$
$
Property Tax Estimate
Annual tax burden & affordability
Select state & enter value to calculate
Check Reviews & Ratings
We recommend verifying businesses through trusted review platforms before making a decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's a realistic home price in Rochester right now, and does it change who I should hire as a Realtor?
Look, Rochester is one of the more affordable metros in NY, and a lot of single-family homes in the city and inner suburbs have landed somewhere in the low-to-mid $100s to the $250s range, while places like Pittsford, Brighton, and Penfield can run well above that (often $300K to $500K+). Prices shift with the market, so treat any range as a rough guide and check recent comparable sales with your agent. Here's the thing: at lower price points, make sure your Realtor actually enjoys working those deals and knows the city neighborhoods and older housing stock, because some agents quietly steer toward bigger commissions. In the suburbs, you want someone who knows each school district and town's quirks.
How do I make sure a Realtor in Rochester is actually licensed and legit?
Here's the thing: in NY, anyone can say they're an 'agent,' but you can look up a real estate salesperson or broker license through the NY Department of State's online license lookup, and you should do it before signing anything. Also know the distinction: 'Realtor' is a trademarked term for licensed agents who are NAR members and follow its Code of Ethics, so a licensed agent isn't automatically a Realtor. If someone claims to be a Realtor in Rochester, you can verify membership through the local association. Check that the license is active and that the agent is hanging it under a legitimate brokerage. Take two minutes to verify; it's free and it weeds out the sketchy ones.
When's the best time of year to buy or sell a house in Rochester?
Rochester winters are no joke (lake-effect snow doesn't exactly make for pretty curb appeal), so spring is traditionally the busiest season for listings, and homes often move fast from roughly April through early summer. Sellers commonly do well listing in spring when yards look good and buyers are active. Buyers, on the other hand, sometimes find less competition and more motivated sellers in late fall and winter, though selection is thinner. Honestly, local inventory and interest rates matter as much as the calendar, so ask your Realtor what's actually happening in your price range and neighborhood rather than relying on a rule of thumb.
What should I ask a Realtor before I sign anything with them?
Look, ask how they get paid, what the commission is, and whether it's negotiable, because since recent industry changes, buyer agent compensation is something you should discuss and have in writing up front. Ask to see the representation agreement before you commit, and find out how long it runs and how you can get out if it isn't working. Press them on dual agency: will they ever represent both the buyer and seller in a Rochester deal, and how would they handle that conflict? In NY, you should receive the required agency disclosure form early on. Also ask how many clients they're juggling and who actually answers your calls, because some agents hand you off to an assistant.
How long does it take to go from accepted offer to closing in Rochester?
In the Rochester area, a typical purchase often takes somewhere around 30 to 60 days from accepted offer to closing, though cash deals can be quicker and complicated financing can stretch it out. Expect steps like attorney review (NY deals generally involve attorneys), inspection, appraisal, mortgage commitment, and title work. Here's the thing: older Rochester homes can turn up issues at inspection that lead to renegotiation, which can add some time. A good Realtor keeps you on top of each deadline so nothing slips, and your attorney handles the legal side of the contract.
What credentials should I actually care about when picking a Realtor in NY?
First, an active NY license (salesperson or broker) and, if they use the title, Realtor membership. Beyond that, designations can help but they're not magic: things like ABR for buyer representation or SRS for seller representation signal extra training, but experience in your specific Rochester neighborhood usually matters more. Ask how many deals they've closed recently in your area and price range, and ask for a few recent client references. Honestly, a part-time agent with a fancy alphabet soup after their name may serve you worse than a full-timer who lives and breathes Monroe County.
What red flags or scams should I watch for with Realtors in Rochester?
Watch out for pressure to use a specific in-house lender or affiliated title or inspection company, because you're allowed to shop around and compare, and a pushy agent who insists otherwise is waving a flag. Another one is undisclosed dual agency, where the same agent or brokerage ends up representing both sides without clearly explaining it to you. Be wary of agents who guarantee an unrealistically high listing price just to win your business, then drop the price later, and anyone who rushes you to sign a long exclusive agreement. Also be careful with wire transfer requests near closing: confirm instructions by phone with a number you already trust, since email wire fraud is a real problem in real estate everywhere, including Rochester.
Does it really matter if I hire a Realtor who knows Rochester instead of someone from out of town?
Yes, it matters more than people think. Rochester is a patchwork: city neighborhoods like the South Wedge, Park Avenue, and Charlotte feel nothing like Pittsford, Webster, or Greece, and each has its own pricing patterns, taxes, and school considerations. A local Realtor knows which streets flood, which older homes tend to have knob-and-tube wiring or aging sewer lines, and how property taxes vary across Monroe County towns, which can seriously affect your monthly costs. They also know local attorneys, inspectors, and lenders who actually show up and perform. Someone from out of the area can handle paperwork, but they won't have that on-the-ground feel for NY's Rochester market, and that's where good deals (and bad surprises) are decided.
Popular Categories in Rochester
Explore Other Cities
🏡 Realtors near Rochester
Professional Categories in Rochester, NY
Related Services from Similar Professionals